Friday, February 16, 2018

The Missing Piece

Scope creep. Two words that we don’t want to deal with and yet we face every day in the midst of a project. What starts as a solid plan may get waylaid by seemingly good intentions that carry the finish line further and further away and which may have rippling effects on stakeholders and end users alike.

Fortunately, I’ve not dealt with a great deal of scope creep within the projects I’ve worked on or been a part of as a team member. I can say that one thing we focus on heavily within my company is ensuring deadlines and deliverable dates are feasible and realistic. The theme seems to be that if we think it can be done in 5 days, it’s better to say 7-8 and deliver early than deal with the aftermath of delivering late. Better to under promise and over deliver than overpromise and under deliver.
However, one project that I worked on experienced scope creep on a significant scale. We were set to deliver a project within about a two month time frame. Plans were created, SMEs consulted, budgets created, and work was underway. Somewhere in the midst of the project it was discovered that a large chunk of material was unaccounted for. This wasn’t internal material-it was an external resource and quite costly to obtain. Budgets were reworked and recalculated, but there was going to be significant increases to ensure this component would be available. In addition, the missing piece would also take an additional six weeks to obtain. You can only imagine the team’s horror at discovering that this was overlooked-but from an ordering standpoint of now needing an additional 6 weeks, but also in cost. To make matters worse, the missing piece had to be in place before making any additional progress on the other components.

To fast forward to the end of the story, the missing piece did take all of the full six weeks to be delivered, the project was over time budget now by seven weeks due to the delays. In addition, several thousand dollars were added to the budget. Stakeholders, especially those holding the purse strings, were not happy. End users were not happy as the wait impacted the results they were looking to achieve in the short term which then in turn impacted the long term. The members of the team were placed on hold for the six weeks and then needed to move frantically, working long hours at great cost to complete the project.


Looking back, this was a simple error. It was simply an oversight of the needed or missing component. Were it not a critical piece to the remainder of the project it wouldn’t have been a big deal in the long run. However, since it was a linchpin component, it meant that production was stopped and budgets inflated. It did teach me an incredibly valuable lesson. Account for all pieces. If you think you have them all, if you think you have all of the pieces to the puzzle-ask someone else to count them. Ensure you have a second and even third pair of eyes on the project before beginning, before promising, and certainly before delivering. 

4 comments:

  1. Melissa,

    You stated "Better to under promise and over deliver than overpromise and under deliver" and I couldn't agree more. A project timeline can be so iffy and if a Project Manager is not careful, it can make her look incompetent. The key is to create a timeline that is realistic and not optimistic. I like the idea of scheduling past the actual time in case there is need for extra time.

    Thanks for your post.

    -S

    ReplyDelete
  2. Melissa,
    When I first started working on projects, or putting the pieces together, I had a much more laissez-faire approach. I figured, things will come into place along the way, and everything will be fine. Well I was wrong! I find it to be much more productive and less stressful to over analyze and make these predictions for the sake of the project. When I first started to account for all these pieces, it showed me the embrace the Type A personality within, because I will thank myself in the end.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Melissa,
    Thank you for sharing. As I read your missing piece, I immediately thought about how program management software that keeps track of individual components could help. Were you able to use such software during this project? I've never used these types of technological tools since none of the projects I've been involved were of the magnitude which would necessitate such tools. Either that or I was not educated on the use of these tools at the time; or both. Nonetheless, I can certainly see value for them being used just to keep track of everything necessary to make a project successful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Melissa, Almost every project manager I have ever seen pads the cost and time to cover the unexpected. We are expected to come in under or on time and budget. When you think about it the only way to really do that is to over estimate. Then we are covered when the unexpected happens. I have always appreciated Montgomery Scott on Star Trek who often was giving advice about being the miracle worker by managing expectations then beating them.

    ReplyDelete